What do you think the rarest fish is?

[Hermione_is_my_idol]

Which fish do you think is the rarest? I think the devil ray, because I have tried and tried to get it, but it never comes. What do you think?

[Sarah]

i said the devil ray cuz its like almost impossible to get. i had it one off my toons be4 but idk how i got it lol

[Mr.toon]

once i tried for 4 hours straight and diddnt get the devil ray definately the hardest 1 2 get:13b:

[C.P. Whiskerseed]

I don't know if I advanced my fishin rod too fast,but I've been trying to catch a Holy Mackeral since I had my Hardwood rod,compared to a Devil ray which I've just started hunting.

Holy mackeral wins for length.

[-Yippie-]

For some reason, I caught Devil Ray easily in the Brrrgh. I was really lucky. I'm not so lucky at catching All Stars though!

[thomas199567]

I have tried and tried and tried at catching the Devil Ray but it is just so hard

[Matt Wild Horse]

I have two maxed fishing toons and both have caught the over 10 devil rays each. It is a ultra rare, don't get me wrong, but it can be caught anywhere and tends to happen at some point somewhere sometime while you are fishing for something else. So in my opinion the Devil Ray is the easiest of the ultra rares.

The full moon was my last fish on both toons.

[Blinky Trickyspinner]

Originally Posted by Matt Wild Horse

I have two maxed fishing toons and both have caught the over 10 devil rays each. It is a ultra rare, don't get me wrong, but it can be caught anywhere and tends to happen at some point somewhere sometime while you are fishing for something else. So in my opinion the Devil Ray is the easiest of the ultra rares.

The full moon was my last fish on both toons.

I agree that full moon is the rarest. On my second toon, I have been fishing over 50,000 just for it, but I was too lucky on my first toon which took only 10 buckets. Also, their have been people who took 100,000 fish just to catch it.

I also caught the devil ray 10+ times and already 4 times on my second toon so its really easy!

Edit: Ooo! I also caught devil ray on the third bt and I didnt even try.

[Zachary and Jake]

i think the all star is, cuz i got the devil ray awhile back and didn't even know it was a rare fish, cuz i got it when i was like a 60(i got it on my 109)

[Hermione_is_my_idol]

Originally Posted by Blinky Trickyspinner

I agree that full moon is the rarest. On my second toon, I have been fishing over 50,000 just for it, but I was too lucky on my first toon which took only 10 buckets. Also, their have been people who took 100,000 fish just to catch it.

I also caught the devil ray 10+ times and already 4 times on my second toon so its really easy!

Edit: Ooo! I also caught devil ray on the third bt and I didnt even try.

devil ray doesn't come for me, and i am 115 laff, soon to be 117. anyways, i got the full moon within 5 buckets! so i guess i got lucky w/ that, i still can't get the devil ray, all star, concord pb&j, and the baby grand. but i still think the devil ray is, or the all star.