Which fish should I go after?

[Sir Dudley]

I still need these:
Devil Ray Fish = any pond ( extremely rare )
All Star Fish = TTC, MM, TB, DL ( extremely rare )
Scurvy Cutthroat Trout = DD & Punchline Place in TTC ( extremely rare )
Holey Mackerel = Estate, DG,TB, & DL ( extremely rare )
Baby Grand Piano Tuna = MM ( extremely rare )
Full Moon Fish = DL ( ? )
Kodiac Bear Acuda = TB ( very rare )
Grizzly Bear Acuda = TB ( extremely rare )
Grand Piano Tuna = MM ( extremely rare )

[Loosy Goosy]

I'm assuming you have gold rod?

I'd go after these next, in this order:
Scurvy (Lighthouse Lane)
Kodiac (Brrrgh PG)
Holey Mackeral (in your estate)

The rest, well, they're pretty tough! I'd say you should try to bag the Piano
Tuna's after you get those three.

Good luck!

[Sir Dudley]

I have the steel rod. Would the gold rod catch these fish better? I have it in my cattlelog.

[Loosy Goosy]

Originally Posted by Sir Dudley

I have the steel rod. Would the gold rod catch these fish better? I have it in my cattlelog.

Don't buy the gold rod until you caught those three, and even then I'd wait! Gold
rod may not cost as much to cast, but it still doesn't yield new species very well.

[Batleth]

I'd have to agree with Loosy here. Looks like your down to some pretty hard catches. Your not about to get any of those too easily, but keep at it and you'll get them.

[Master Chip Wonderslam]

Originally Posted by Sir Dudley

I have the steel rod. Would the gold rod catch these fish better? I have it in my cattlelog.

Don't sweat the rarest of fish. Loosy gives good advise. I just caught the All Star in the Brrrgh while trying to get the Kodiak (which I got 2 casts later). Those rarest of fish come when you least expect em. Enjoy!!

[Marlu's Dad]

I'd do The Brrrgh. It's the pond that has most fish you still need.