Honestly, I don't care which strategy is used. Either way works for me, as long as no one goes sad, and we win. I've won 29/30 CEO's(The one I lost was due to a bug, so I wouldn't even consider it a loss. I pressed "x" to jump off of the table, and it didn't let me jump off, so he ran me over, and I somehow lost 57 laff points from that..). Anyway, I've done it every way possible; with 4 golfers, with all seltzer, with 4 toon's just standing by the conveyor belts the whole time, waiting for toon-up(Don't prefer this one

). Every way works.
I do prefer everyone to seltzer, if I'm with a group of experienced toon's. Yesterday I did two all seltzer CEO's and each took 10 minutes or less; one even took 6-7 minutes.